Assessing Maturity and Adoption
Assessing Governance Maturity and Adoption
You've spent the last unit measuring whether individual data is trustworthy. Now zoom out. How do you measure whether the governance effort itself is working? Picture a colleague telling you in the hallway that the program is "maturing nicely." What would you need to see to believe that, or to gently disagree? That question is the whole point of this unit: replacing the warm feeling of progress with something you can actually point to.
What Does "Mature" Actually Mean?
Here's the trap most people fall into: they treat maturity as one number, or worse, one gut feeling. But "mature" is as vague as "good data" was last unit. Mature at what?
The Five-Level Maturity Model gives you a ladder to answer that. At the bottom is Initial, where things only work through individual heroics and luck, with nothing consistent. Next is Managed, where a few habits repeat but nobody has written them down. Then Defined, where the practice is documented and standard. Then Measured, where you actually track whether it's working. And at the top, Optimizing, where you deliberately improve it over time.
But a ladder of what, exactly? That's where the Maturity Dimensions come in: five areas you rate separately. There's people and roles (does anyone actually own decisions?), process and decision forums (do issues get resolved in a regular rhythm, or only when someone panics?), data and artifacts (glossaries, catalogs, standards that genuinely exist), policy and standards (written and adopted, or just aspirational?), and enablement or adoption (do people know about any of this and use it?).
Here's why splitting them matters. A team can be surprisingly advanced in one dimension and primitive in another: a polished glossary for one domain (early Defined on data) while nobody is accountable for any decision (Initial on people). Anyone who says "we have a glossary, so we're mature" has rated one dimension and assumed the rest. The dimensions force the sharper question: mature where?

Rate the Evidence, Not the Effort
